Beating Broke

Personal Finance from the Broke Perspective

Our Experience Bypassing Auto Insurance

By Leave a Comment

Bypassing Auto Insurance

A few years ago, my husband and I decided to travel with our then three-year-old to visit my alma mater. We were driving around, seeing the sites when we were rear-ended. The driver, a man in his thirties like us, was apologetic and gave us his license, name, and number. And then he said that he wanted to pay for the damages himself, bypassing auto insurance.

Our Experience Bypassing Auto Insurance

I don’t know the details of why this man wanted to bypass auto insurance. I assumed he already had some claims on his insurance and didn’t want to add more. Not only would that raise the price of his insurance, but if he had several claims on his insurance in a short time, his insurance company might drop his coverage.

My husband and I lived five hours from my alma mater, so all communication was done via phone.

Getting an Estimate

I went to a local repair shop and got an estimate for the damage. The total came to $1,462. I got a copy of the receipt and sent it to the man who hit us.

He didn’t ask for a second opinion. He accepted the quote and promptly sent me a check. However, when I received the payment, he had transversed his numbers and sent us $1,642, $180 more than the estimate.

I notified him about the overpayment, but he didn’t want to hassle with anything. He told me to keep the extra money. At this point, I think he just wanted to get the repair done.

We Were Lucky

Looking back, the man who rear-ended us was lucky because my husband and I are honest. I knew that the man was trusting us, so I went to a shop we had used for repairs before and that I trusted. I didn’t try to milk the man for more money.

We were lucky because the man who hit us was motivated to keep this accident off his insurance record and get the process over and done with. He paid us promptly.

Would I Do It Again?

Bypassing Auto Insurance

Would I bypass auto insurance again? It depends. I recognize that I could have had an issue with the man not paying, but I didn’t. He was honest.

Still, when you bypass auto insurance, you take a risk. If I just had a minor fender bender, I may take that risk again. However, I would write down the other driver’s auto insurance company and policy number, so I would have recourse if he failed to pay.

If the accident was more than a fender bender, no, I would not bypass auto insurance. The repair cost would likely be higher than a thousand dollars, and I wouldn’t want to risk losing that much money. Also, a more significant accident would require calling the police. Then an insurance claim would need to be filed.

Have you ever bypassed auto insurance? If so, what was your experience?

Read More

In a Car Accident? Should You Pay Out of Pocket for Repairs?

Does Your Car Insurance Pay for These Items?

5 Strategies to Buy a Used Car Without Being Scammed

Check Your Car Insurance

By 3 Comments

Way back in March, I mentioned that I was beginning to look into making some adjustments and doing some price checking.  Somewhere in between there and here, life got in the way and I wasn’t able to get it done as quickly as I would have liked.  I’ve finally caught up to it though and I’m glad that I did.

This story should be proof for the rest of you who don’t regularly compare prices on things.  Never assume that you’re getting the best rate.

Our car insurance had been with State Farm.  I have been a customer of theirs for close to a decade.  As of August (when the home owners insurance renews) I will no longer be a customer.  Why?  Because, what I found in my checking is that they were tied for most expensive auto insurance.  And the home owners wasn’t much better.  Of course, your results may vary and the insurance company for us isn’t necessarily going to be the company for you.  I know that when I originally signed up with State Farm, it was because the price comparison tool at Progressives website pointed to them as being the cheapest.

I find it ironic that the insurance company that we’re moving to is Progressive.  We’ll be moving our Home Owners policy to someone else.  Progressive was almost exactly 50% cheaper than State Farm.  50%!!!  In fact, the total for 6 months for all three vehicles that we insure was just barely more than it was for just one of them at State Farm.  That’s pretty incredible.  A bit of trivium; our new ins. agent mentioned that he’s moved 11 clients from State Farm to Progressive in the last month or so, and that about 6 Progressive clients have moved to State Farm.  I mention that to concrete the idea that the right insurance company for one person isn’t necessarily the right insurance company for another.  With all the variables that they take into account, it’s hard to say which will be better unless you do some shopping.

Another interesting note from the adventure.  Previously, I went to a State Farm agent and got my insurance.  This time, I went to an insurance agency.  They’re independent for the most part and have access to several insurance companies to quote from.  That makes it much easier to shop around, as they will do most of the footwork for you.  All you’ve got to do is check any companies that you’d like quotes from that the agency doesn’t have a relationship with. In our case, Allstate was probably the biggest one that the agency didn’t have to quote from.  I used Allstate’s online quote tool and found it to be on par with State Farm.

So, lesson learned.  Shopping around is good.  It can help you find the best deal when you’re buying just about anything.  But, if you’re buying a service, remember to shop around periodically and compare the service that used to be the best deal to make sure it still is.  You just might do like we did and save 50%.

Do You Shop Your Insurance?

By 2 Comments

My wife and I are thinking of selling our house and buying something a bit bigger.  The house we are in is a little small for our expanding family.  It could be done, but not very comfortably.  In that process, we started our research by visiting with a loan officer to run some numbers and make sure that we were shopping in a price range that we could afford.

One of the subjects that came up in the process is the subject of home owners insurance.  As we discussed it, I mentioned what we were currently paying.  And then the discussion really started.  Turns out, our loan officer thinks that we are over paying by quite a bit.  By about 40% if the loan officer is even close to correct.  Ouch.

When we bought our house, the insurance was the last thing on my mind.  When the day came to sign all the paperwork, the loan officer that we were using at the time (not the same one we saw the other day) asked for the proof of insurance.  Which I did not have, because I had not gotten the insurance yet.  I didn’t see the purpose in insuring a house that I didn’t technically own yet.  I was wrong.  I couldn’t take ownership without proof of insurance.  Two very quick trips to the insurance agent that has our car insurance account later, I had my home owners insurance, and was able to sign the paperwork and take ownership.

In my haste, I took what I could get and what the agent suggested.  Because our house loan has an escrow account, I never really see the bill for the insurance.  It never really got brought up, and it just continued on it’s merry way.  I fell prey to a common personal financial mistake.  I didn’t shop around.  And I didn’t revisit my policies to check for pricing and coverage.

Committing that mistake may only be costing me a few hundred dollars a year.  I say only, because it could certainly be much worse.  Now, as we begin shopping for a new house, we’ll also be shopping for insurance.  Depending on what we find, we may be changing agents.  We may even change agents for the auto coverage as well since we’ll be shopping that around as well.  It doesn’t hurt to look, right?

I know I’m not the only one to ever fall victim to this error.  If you’d like to share your story, you can in the comments below.